[Rseding91] [0.17.69] Rotating not rotateable Assembler results in offgrid placement

[TheFunnySide]

To reproduce this:
-have an assembler on the cursor
-press r for rotate
-it now places 0.5 tiles to the side.
-Its collision box is not rotated(this part is correctly working)

The assembler cant have a pipe connection else it is allowed to rotate normaly
The assembler has to have different width to height.
This worked for me:
collision_box = {{-1.7, -2.2}, {1.7, 2.2}},
selection_box = {{-2.0, -2.5}, {2.0, 2.5}},


This can be prevented by placing the "not-rotatable" flag

[Rseding91]

Thanks for the report however I don't understand: what part of it is "not rotatable" when it doesn't have the "not-rotatable" flag defined?

[TheFunnySide]

I attached an number of images showing that the assembler is ofset by 0.5 tiles after pressing r before placing. Its collision box is also not rotated.

[DaveMcW]

The assembler cant have a pipe connection else it is allowed to rotate normaly

Assembling machine rotation is not supported unless it has a pipe.

[Bilka]

The assembler cant have a pipe connection else it is allowed to rotate normaly

Assembling machine rotation is not supported unless it has a pipe.

Wrong.

Note that a crafting machine cannot be rotated unless it has at least one of the following: a fluid box, a heat energy source, a fluid energy source, or a non-square collision box. Crafting machines with non-square collision boxes can only be rotated before placement, not after.

[Rseding91]

Thanks for the additional information. It's now fixed for the next version of 0.17.

[boskid]

I think there will be more issues here.
Since this CraftingMachine is not square and there is no option for mods to prevent it from rotating while in simulation (before building) mod author will need to provide graphics for 90deg rotation.

Above mentioned fix will only prevent rotation of existing building (since allowing rotation here would require updating entity position and checking for collisions with other entities).

For now there is also no way for lua to prevent player from rotating simulation since this does not produce InputActions (so there is no lag on multiplayer with showing where entity is going to be placed).
Full fix would be something like pre 0.17 rocket-silo that was 9x10, was not rotatable even in simulation and was causing blueprint to only be placable in two directions (0deg and 180deg).

Extra catch here is that CraftingMachine that is not square but has pipe connections, should be allowed to rotate like a boiler: by 180deg on single rotate action.

[Bilka]

I think there will be more issues here.
Since this CraftingMachine is not square and there is no option for mods to prevent it from rotating while in simulation (before building) mod author will need to provide graphics for 90deg rotation.

There's https://wiki.factorio.com/Types/EntityP ... tatable.22 which TheFunnySide is using to work around this bug.

Above mentioned fix will only prevent rotation of existing building (since allowing rotation here would require updating entity position and checking for collisions with other entities).

So, same as before, see the wiki quote.

For now there is also no way for lua to prevent player from rotating simulation since this does not produce InputActions (so there is no lag on multiplayer with showing where entity is going to be placed).
Full fix would be something like pre 0.17 rocket-silo that was 9x10, was not rotatable even in simulation and was causing blueprint to only be placable in two directions (0deg and 180deg).

Which is what https://wiki.factorio.com/Types/EntityP ... tatable.22 does.

[boskid]

There's https://wiki.factorio.com/Types/EntityP ... tatable.22 which TheFunnySide is using to work around this bug.

Oh i see. So this issue (after fix) that can be triggered by rotating before building:

sheep-farm-pre-rotate.png (86.61 KiB) Viewed 4338 times

Is caused by sheep farm not using "not-rotatable" flag in its prototype and this is mod issue, not game issue.

sheep farm prototype

Code: Select all

        --Sheep farm
        {
            type = "assembling-machine",
            ------------------
            fixed_recipe = "sheep_wool",
            crafting_categories = {"predetermined"},
            ingredient_count = 1,
            crafting_speed = 1,
            ---------------------

            name = "sheep_farm",
            icon = "__Annotorio__/graphics/icons/sheep_farm_icon.png",
            icon_size = 64,
            flags = {"placeable-neutral", "placeable-player", "player-creation"},
            minable = {mining_time = 0.2, result = "sheep_farm"},
            max_health = 300,
            dying_explosion = "medium-explosion",
            corpse = "medium-remnants",