Addition to fluids 2.0

Post your ideas and suggestions how to improve the game.

Moderator: ickputzdirwech

User avatar
Hovel
Inserter
Inserter
Posts: 21
Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2016 7:32 pm
Contact:

Addition to fluids 2.0

Post by Hovel »

I am aware that the FFF fluids 2.0 is closed. It is not my intention to continue the same discussion here. I only like to share my idea to add to the new fluids 2.0 system.
TL;DR
Add more challenge to fluids, but not changing the new fluid 2.0 system.
What ?
As a process engineer I have done quite a few hydraulic calculation of flow through pipes of fluids. The pump in factorio visually represents a possitive displacement pump, more specific a plunger pump. The flowrate of possitive displacement pump will not change if you increase pipeline and therefore pump head pressure. As long as the pump has enough power (from the electic motor) and mechanical strenght, you can increase pipe length.

To add a bit more challenge to the new fluid dynamics of factorio 2.0, I would suggest that the power a pump draws is depending on the total connected pipes. Irl this is a liniair function. If the pump doesn't have a minimum power draw, it won't matter if you use 1 pump of more for the same length of pipe. Adding a minimum power drain would only encourage to use as few pumps as possible. That why I would suggest to use a exponential relationship between pipe length and power draw.

If you would use 10kw * 1,03^pipelength, you would get the following results for power draw:

Image

Additionally tanks, wagons, assembling machines, refineries etc, could all have a pipe length "representation". Each connected tank could be 10 "extra" pipe lengths for instance, maybe assembling machines/refineries/chemicalplants 20 pipe lengths and nuclear reactors 50.

Image
Why ?
This will add more challenge to fluid dynamics, without being complicated. Pumps could even show how "much" total pipe length is connected too clearify to players.

Results of this change:
  1. be efficient with pipe layout and get rewarded with less power draw.
  2. trains stay best long distance solution.
  3. still have high flowrate to large amount of assembling machines/refineries/chemical plants in late-/endgame if you provide enough power.
Please only share thoughts on this specific idea and leave the main discussion of fluids 2.0 out of this topic.
DrentalBot
Manual Inserter
Manual Inserter
Posts: 4
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2024 8:53 am
Contact:

Re: Addition to fluids 2.0

Post by DrentalBot »

I thought about it some more and I had another thought.

With the changes there still is a challenge that we can need to solve, it's how many pumps you need between fluid system segments to account for maximum throughputs between sections that need pressure control. Especially with the crazy fast builds that we might be able to make and how they could outpace what a single pump can move.

That's it. That's all I needed to realize to be happy. The FFF even has an example of this with two pumps moving the petroleum gas out of the cracking line.

So to that specific Idea: I think it's adding complexity in a place that is usually invisible in the game and can cause unexpected results in the Power grid when you add a little expansion. Also, I don't see that it's needed to create interesting design decisions into the Fluid mechanics.
Add to that that this might increase the value of underground pipes again in a similar way to the Fluids 1.0 version.
Post Reply

Return to “Ideas and Suggestions”