[0.17.11] (minor) mining prod research prerequisite

[ruy16109]

Finite miner researches do not yet require respective science packs. This is contrary to the common practice where you first unlock the science pack then the techs that use it. See picture.

Untitled-1.png (4.45 MiB) Viewed 2861 times

[ruy16109]

Additionally, the following techs also have the same issue:

worker speed 3-5, inserter stack 3-7, laser turret speed 3-7, energy damage 4-6, character trash slot 2-5, character logistic slot 3-6, follower count 3-4, brake force 3-6, worker cargo 2-3. No picture for those because that would be excessive, but one can check them in game.

[ruy16109]

My suggestion is to auto-require science packs which can also help modding, but manually putting those prerequisites in would also be fine.

[ruy16109]

Related: viewtopic.php?f=7&t=67193

[ManaUser]

My understanding is that they made a deliberate decision not to make the extra science packs a formal requirement for the higher levels of multi-level research. The main reasoning being that it seems obvious enough anyway and that adding these would make the tech tree over-complicated and ugly.

[ruy16109]

My understanding is that they made a deliberate decision not to make the extra science packs a formal requirement for the higher levels of multi-level research. The main reasoning being that it seems obvious enough anyway and that adding these would make the tech tree over-complicated and ugly.

This, however, does not explain why infinite researches require space science to unlock, from 0.17.2 (viewtopic.php?f=3&t=65580). My point is that sticking with either strategy is fine, but having both strategies in different parts is not.

[ruy16109]

Also when I was digging through release notes, I found this post (viewtopic.php?p=401129) that is marked solved and mentioned in 0.17.2. It seems that said post was pointing at essentially the same issue as I had pointed out, but the fix in 0.17.2 was so specific that only first tiers were requiring science packs, whereas I am pointing out that all tiers should.

[ManaUser]

This, however, does not explain why infinite researches require space science to unlock, from 0.17.2 (viewtopic.php?f=3&t=65580). My point is that sticking with either strategy is fine, but having both strategies in different parts is not.

You're right. That does seem a bit weird.

[Bilka]

See viewtopic.php?p=401353#p401353:

Other mid-tiers of number upgrades do not get all the pre-requisites as that should already be obvious from science pack icons under the technology icons, and it would probably make the technology tree look way too messy.